TCGTalk Logo
Today
Pokemon▼ -0.10%Yugioh▼ -0.36%Magic▼ -0.03%One Piece▼ -0.35%Top Gainer · Black Belt [1st Edition] #77▲ +68587.2%Top Loser · Torchic #73▼ -99.1%Biggest Rise · Black Belt [1st Edition] #77▲ +S$1,605Biggest Drop · Celebi [1st Edition] #91▼ −S$919SG Avg Price Diff+64.3%Avg Arbitrage Savings4.2%Market Efficiency79.1%Pokemon▼ -0.10%Yugioh▼ -0.36%Magic▼ -0.03%One Piece▼ -0.35%Top Gainer · Black Belt [1st Edition] #77▲ +68587.2%Top Loser · Torchic #73▼ -99.1%Biggest Rise · Black Belt [1st Edition] #77▲ +S$1,605Biggest Drop · Celebi [1st Edition] #91▼ −S$919SG Avg Price Diff+64.3%Avg Arbitrage Savings4.2%Market Efficiency79.1%
Live prices →
Guides›Price Analysis›Magic · Market Data · Foils · 2026

Top 100 Most Liquid Magic: The Gathering Cards: Prices & 30-Day Analysis (October 2026)

The 100 most actively traded Magic: The Gathering singles ranked by annual sales volume, with ungraded and graded prices, a foil/treatment breakdown, and a 30-day change tracker vs September 2026. A raw-driven, play-first market.

Top 100 Most Liquid Magic: The Gathering Cards: Prices & 30-Day Analysis (October 2026)
Advertisement

What Is Card Liquidity?

Liquidity describes how easily an asset can be bought or sold at a stable price. In the Magic: The Gathering market, a liquid card is one with many active buyers and sellers — you can list it today and expect a quick sale at or near market value.

We measure liquidity using annual sales volume from PriceCharting: the number of verified transactions recorded per card per year. Magic's liquidity is driven by playability — Commander, Modern, Legacy, and Standard demand — far more than by grading. High liquidity matters for:

  • Players — format staples are easy to pick up at fair prices when brewing a deck
  • Sellers — liquid cards move quickly without requiring steep discounts
  • Price accuracy — more transactions mean listed prices reflect real market consensus
  • Speculators — you can exit positions without waiting months for a buyer

All prices below come from PriceCharting daily CSV snapshots: current (October 3, 2026) vs baseline (September 3, 2026) for a 30-day change view. Sealed product (bundles, booster boxes, Commander decks) is excluded — this is a singles-only ranking.

Market Snapshot — October 2026

Most Liquid Card
Draft Night
The Hobbit · 485 sales/yr
Median Ungraded
$9.26
across top 100
Average Ungraded
$32.56
across top 100
Foils in Top 100
35
of 100 cards
Most Represented Set
85
The Hobbit
Cards With Graded Data
5
of 100 — Magic barely grades

Magic liquidity concentrates in the newest sets — The Hobbit alone supplies 85 of the top 100, followed by Marvel Super Heroes (5) and Secret Lair Drop (4). With a median ungraded price of $9.26, these are playable singles that everyday Magic players trade constantly, not trophy pieces locked away.

A striking 98 of the top 100 cards were released in 2025–2026. Magic's secondary market is overwhelmingly driven by what's currently being opened, drafted, and played — fresh staples generate deep markets within weeks of release.

30-Day Price Movers (September 3 → October 3, 2026)

Ungraded price changes across the top 100. Filtered to cards priced ≥$5 to exclude low-value price noise.

Biggest Gainers

#CardSetSeptember PriceOctober PriceChange
#42Thorin, Mountain-king [Borderless Foil] #279The Hobbit$110.00$130.30+18.5% ▲
#7Radagast of Rhosgobel [Extended Art Foil] #309The Hobbit$11.62$13.49+16.1% ▲
#84Knuckles The Echidna #2082Secret Lair Drop$18.92$21.21+12.1% ▲
#52Radagast of Rhosgobel [Extended Art] #309The Hobbit$6.12$6.67+9.0% ▲
#28Dancing from Dark to Dawn [Showcase] #231The Hobbit$9.94$10.77+8.4% ▲
#14The Queen of Dale [Showcase Foil] #253The Hobbit$125.00$134.99+8.0% ▲
#99Gollum, Riddle Master [Borderless Foil] #277The Hobbit$109.05$117.47+7.7% ▲
#9The Great Goblin [Borderless Foil] #201The Hobbit$7.43$7.98+7.4% ▲
#49The Queen of Dale [Showcase] #217The Hobbit$21.50$22.24+3.4% ▲
#46Stay with Me #31Final Fantasy Through the Ages$97.49$100.50+3.1% ▲
#12Smaug the Magnificent [Showcase] #229The Hobbit$44.00$45.00+2.3% ▲

Biggest Losers

#CardSetSeptember PriceOctober PriceChange
#19Bilbo, Thief in the Night [Showcase] #219The Hobbit$26.08$11.85-54.6% ▼
#59Bilbo, Thief in the Night #33The Hobbit$15.88$9.00-43.3% ▼
#54Gandalf, Goblins' Bane #96The Hobbit$8.00$5.06-36.8% ▼
#87Gleaming Splendor [Borderless] #239The Hobbit$102.33$70.00-31.6% ▼
#27Orcrist, Goblin-cleaver [Foil] #177The Hobbit$17.99$12.33-31.5% ▼
#20Gleaming Splendor [Foil] #15The Hobbit$52.39$36.04-31.2% ▼
#61Gleaming Splendor #15The Hobbit$41.85$29.04-30.6% ▼
#43Thranduil, the Elvenking [Borderless Foil] #282The Hobbit$123.19$86.00-30.2% ▼
#91Fateful Discovery [Showcase] #220The Hobbit$9.31$6.50-30.2% ▼
#57Beorn the Fierce #119The Hobbit$8.25$6.00-27.3% ▼

The Liquidity Spectrum

The most liquid Magic cards span an enormous price range — from bulk-priced format staples that sell by the playset to four-figure chase pieces — yet all of them change hands constantly. One representative card at each price tier:

Price TierExample CardSetPriceWhy It Trades
EntryDesolation of Smaug #93The Hobbit$0.97Format-staple common/uncommon — pennies each, sells by the playset
MidFateful Discovery [Foil] #40The Hobbit$4.86Playable rare or set chase with steady constructed demand
PremiumSmaug the Impenetrable [Borderless] #9The Hobbit Eternal$18.49High-demand mythic or marquee reprint — broad cross-format appeal
TrophyGleaming Splendor [Borderless Foil] #275The Hobbit$505.35Marquee chase card or serialized print — collector-grade liquidity

Set Dominance

Magic's secondary-market volume skews hard toward recent releases. Players and collectors trade most heavily in the sets currently in print and in rotation — older cards stay liquid mainly as cross-format staples and Reserved List investments.

Most Represented Sets

SetCards in Top 100
The Hobbit85
Marvel Super Heroes5
Secret Lair Drop4
The Hobbit Eternal3
Promo2
Final Fantasy Through the Ages1

Release Era

EraCards in Top 100
2025–202698

Treatment & Foil Breakdown

35 of the top 100 are foils. Modern Magic sets ship a dizzying array of special treatments — borderless, extended art, showcase frames, retro frames — and these alternate versions drive both desirability and price. Breakdown of the top 100 by treatment:

TreatmentCount in Top 100Median Price
Regular (non-foil)35$3.99
Foil22$6.10
Borderless16$20.98
Showcase11$11.85
Borderless Foil9$117.47
Extended Art3$6.67
Showcase Foil2$257.75
Extended Art Foil2$13.49

Treatment is inferred from the bracketed label in each card's name. Foil and special-frame versions consistently carry higher median prices than the regular non-foil printing of the same card — the premium collectors pay for the fancy version.

Grading Reality Check

Here is the starkest contrast between Magic and Pokémon. In Pokémon, a PSA 10 routinely commands a 5×–30× premium over raw. Magic barely grades at all.

Of the 100 most liquid Magic cards, only 5 have any graded sale on record — the thinnest graded participation of any major TCG we track. Magic is overwhelmingly a play-and-trade-raw market: value lives in near-mint ungraded copies, and most players never slab their cards. Grading is reserved for vintage Power Nine, Reserved List staples, and serialized chase cards — almost none of which appear in a liquidity ranking dominated by current-set singles.

The Few Cards With a Graded Premium

The rare exceptions in this top 100 where a graded copy does command a premium over raw:

#CardSetUngradedGradedPremium
#2Sonic The Hedgehog [Foil] #2087Secret Lair Drop$4.12$75.0018.2×
#38Food #2808Secret Lair Drop$5.00$50.0010×
#51Doctor Doom [Borderless] #394Marvel Super Heroes$140.46$212.011.51×
#84Knuckles The Echidna #2082Secret Lair Drop$21.21$23.001.08×

Sonic The Hedgehog [Foil] #2087 leads at 18.2× ($75.00 graded vs $4.12 raw). For the vast majority of Magic cards, grading fees and a near-nonexistent slab market mean holding raw is the correct call. Use the tcgTalk Price Comparison tool to find raw copies at fair market value.

Price Averages (October 2026)

Use median as your benchmark — not average. A handful of four-figure chase cards pull the average far above typical trading values.

ConditionAvg PriceMedian PriceCards With Data
Ungraded (Raw)$32.56$9.26100/100
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$91.81$75.005/100

Full Top 100 Price List

All prices in USD from PriceCharting (October 3, 2026). Change column shows September 3 → October 3, 2026. "—" means insufficient market data for that condition.

#1 — Draft Night

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 485

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$139.99$133.91-4.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#2 — Sonic The Hedgehog [Foil] #2087

Set: Magic Secret Lair Drop  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 482

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$4.58$4.12-10.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$72.00$75.00+4.2% ▲

#3 — Bilbo's Ring [Borderless Foil] #81

Set: Magic The Hobbit Eternal  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 420

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)—$20.09—
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#4 — Gleaming Splendor [Borderless Foil] #275

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 399

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$615.38$505.35-17.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#5 — Smaug the Magnificent [Showcase Foil] #265

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 377

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$297.97$257.75-13.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#6 — Box Topper

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 358

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$39.49$39.480.0%
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#7 — Radagast of Rhosgobel [Extended Art Foil] #309

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Extended Art Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 354

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$11.62$13.49+16.1% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#8 — Belladonna Took [Foil] #4

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 352

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.25$3.93+20.9% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#9 — The Great Goblin [Borderless Foil] #201

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 352

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$7.43$7.98+7.4% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#10 — The Arkenstone [Borderless] #247

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 349

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$69.38$61.44-11.4% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#11 — Smaug the Magnificent [Foil] #110

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 348

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$29.60$24.27-18.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#12 — Smaug the Magnificent [Showcase] #229

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 348

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$44.00$45.00+2.3% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#13 — Desolation of Smaug [Showcase] #226

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 347

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.32$2.42+4.3% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#14 — The Queen of Dale [Showcase Foil] #253

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 345

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$125.00$134.99+8.0% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#15 — Swords To Plowshares #1

Set: Magic Promo  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 343

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$28.10$27.81-1.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#16 — Thorin, Mountain-king [Borderless] #243

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 342

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$23.75$20.98-11.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#17 — Beorn the Fierce [Showcase] #230

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 341

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$17.53$15.47-11.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#18 — Gandalf, Goblins' Bane [Borderless] #242

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 341

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$31.99$26.04-18.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#19 — Bilbo, Thief in the Night [Showcase] #219

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 339

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$26.08$11.85-54.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#20 — Gleaming Splendor [Foil] #15

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 338

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$52.39$36.04-31.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#21 — Radagast of Rhosgobel [Foil] #136

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 338

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.00$3.09+3.0% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#22 — The Great Goblin [Foil] #158

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 338

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.97$1.83-7.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#23 — The Queen of Dale [Foil] #24

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 338

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$19.99$17.95-10.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#24 — Wizard's Staff [Extended Art Foil] #294

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Extended Art Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 337

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$15.00$12.68-15.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#25 — Desolation of Smaug #93

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 335

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.17$0.97-17.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#26 — Gandalf, Goblins' Bane [Foil] #96

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 333

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$8.33$7.19-13.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#27 — Orcrist, Goblin-cleaver [Foil] #177

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 331

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$17.99$12.33-31.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#28 — Dancing from Dark to Dawn [Showcase] #231

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 329

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$9.94$10.77+8.4% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#29 — The Arkenstone [Foil] #170

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 328

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$13.50$12.57-6.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#30 — Captain America, Super-Soldier [Borderless] #387

Set: Magic Marvel Super Heroes  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 324

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$66.00$62.44-5.4% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#31 — Gandalf, Spark Starter [Borderless Foil] #203

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 324

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.25$1.67+33.6% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#32 — The Arkenstone [Showcase] #234

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 324

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$27.88$26.00-6.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#33 — My Precious [Foil] #176

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 321

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.00$2.50-16.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#34 — Bard, King of Dale [Foil] #144

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 320

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$7.44$6.10-18.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#35 — Belladonna Took [Showcase] #214

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 318

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$5.00$5.000.0%
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#36 — Bilbo, Thief in the Night [Foil] #33

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 318

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$17.49$13.29-24.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#37 — The Lonely Mountain [Borderless] #248

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 318

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$19.15$14.92-22.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#38 — Food #2808

Set: Magic Secret Lair Drop  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 316

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$5.00$5.000.0%
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$50.00$50.000.0%

#39 — Beorn the Fierce [Foil] #119

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 316

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$7.77$7.57-2.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#40 — Dancing from Dark to Dawn [Foil] #123

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$8.70$8.69-0.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#41 — Smaug, Wicked Worm [Foil] #164

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.73$3.25-12.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#42 — Thorin, Mountain-king [Borderless Foil] #279

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$110.00$130.30+18.5% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#43 — Thranduil, the Elvenking [Borderless Foil] #282

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$123.19$86.00-30.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#44 — Thranduil, the Elvenking [Foil] #167

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.21$2.50+13.1% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#45 — Wizard's Staff [Foil] #59

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 314

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$6.05$5.50-9.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#46 — Stay with Me #31

Set: Magic Final Fantasy Through the Ages  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 312

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$97.49$100.50+3.1% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$110.00$99.05-10.0% ▼

#47 — Bard, King of Dale #144

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 311

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$7.00$5.28-24.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#48 — Fateful Discovery #40

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 311

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$4.98$3.87-22.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#49 — The Queen of Dale [Showcase] #217

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 311

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$21.50$22.24+3.4% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#50 — Dancing from Dark to Dawn #123

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 308

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$7.89$6.87-12.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#51 — Doctor Doom [Borderless] #394

Set: Magic Marvel Super Heroes  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 306

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$145.98$140.46-3.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$212.01$212.010.0%

#52 — Radagast of Rhosgobel [Extended Art] #309

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Extended Art  | Annual Sales Volume: 306

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$6.12$6.67+9.0% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#53 — Fateful Discovery [Foil] #40

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 305

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$5.99$4.86-18.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#54 — Gandalf, Goblins' Bane #96

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 305

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$8.00$5.06-36.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#55 — An Unexpected Party #29

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 304

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.64$1.59-3.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#56 — Belladonna Took #4

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$4.24$3.01-29.0% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#57 — Beorn the Fierce #119

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$8.25$6.00-27.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#58 — Bilbo's Gambit #5

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.82$2.13-24.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#59 — Bilbo, Thief in the Night #33

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$15.88$9.00-43.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#60 — Gigantic Big Bear #126

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.05$1.51+43.8% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#61 — Gleaming Splendor #15

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$41.85$29.04-30.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#62 — Gollum, Riddle Master #70

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.01$2.88-4.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#63 — Kili the Resourceful #17

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.67$1.39-16.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#64 — My Precious #176

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.17$2.38+9.7% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#65 — My Precious [Showcase] #235

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$4.26$3.91-8.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#66 — Orcrist, Goblin-cleaver #177

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$16.75$14.42-13.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#67 — Smaug the Magnificent #110

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$24.57$20.98-14.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#68 — Smaug, Wicked Worm #164

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.58$2.01-22.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#69 — Smaug, Wicked Worm [Borderless] #245

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$19.74$15.49-21.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#70 — The Great Goblin #158

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$0.95$1.50+57.9% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#71 — The Great Goblin [Borderless] #201

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$5.09$4.54-10.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#72 — The Sackville-Bagginses #83

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.17$1.51+29.1% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#73 — Thorin, Mountain-king #114

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$4.53$4.20-7.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#74 — Thranduil, the Elvenking #167

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.21$1.84-16.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#75 — Thranduil, the Elvenking [Borderless] #246

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$14.99$11.59-22.7% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#76 — Through the Forest Gate #137

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.83$1.59-13.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#77 — Wizard's Staff #59

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$5.00$3.99-20.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#78 — Wizard's Staff [Extended Art] #294

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Extended Art  | Annual Sales Volume: 303

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$9.12$4.90-46.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#79 — Bard, King of Dale [Borderless] #244

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 302

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$22.66$19.99-11.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#80 — Gandalf, Spark Starter [Borderless] #203

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 302

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.00$1.40+40.0% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#81 — Gollum, Riddle Master [Borderless] #241

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 302

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$20.65$17.91-13.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#82 — Orcrist, Goblin-cleaver [Showcase] #236

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 302

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$23.98$18.93-21.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#83 — The Arkenstone #170

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 302

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$11.75$9.26-21.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#84 — Knuckles The Echidna #2082

Set: Magic Secret Lair Drop  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 297

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$18.92$21.21+12.1% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)$25.00$23.00-8.0% ▼

#85 — Rogue's Passage [Foil] #7112

Set: Magic Secret Lair Drop  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 296

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)—$10.74—
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#86 — Bilbo's Gambit [Foil] #5

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 295

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.01$2.12-29.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#87 — Gleaming Splendor [Borderless] #239

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 295

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$102.33$70.00-31.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#88 — Radagast of Rhosgobel #136

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 295

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$3.48$2.51-27.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#89 — Gandalf, Shadow's Foe [Extended Art] #99

Set: Magic The Hobbit Eternal  | Treatment: Extended Art  | Annual Sales Volume: 295

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$22.25$20.57-7.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#90 — The Arkenstone [Borderless Foil] #283

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 294

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$259.99$210.38-19.1% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#91 — Fateful Discovery [Showcase] #220

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Showcase  | Annual Sales Volume: 290

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$9.31$6.50-30.2% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#92 — Thanos, The Mad Titan [Borderless] #400

Set: Magic Marvel Super Heroes  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 286

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$177.24$174.39-1.6% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#93 — Bruce Banner [Borderless] #390

Set: Magic Marvel Super Heroes  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 285

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$69.33$60.77-12.3% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#94 — Spider-Man, Peter Parker #3

Set: Magic Promo  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 283

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.71$1.63-39.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#95 — Thranduil's Company #168

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 282

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$1.11$1.00-9.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#96 — Gleaming Splendor [Borderless Foil] #239

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 281

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$151.12$149.69-0.9% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#97 — The Queen of Dale #24

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Regular (non-foil)  | Annual Sales Volume: 280

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$20.32$18.74-7.8% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#98 — Hex Magic [Foil] #133

Set: Magic Marvel Super Heroes  | Treatment: Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 276

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$2.50$2.34-6.4% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#99 — Gollum, Riddle Master [Borderless Foil] #277

Set: Magic The Hobbit  | Treatment: Borderless Foil  | Annual Sales Volume: 276

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$109.05$117.47+7.7% ▲
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

#100 — Smaug the Impenetrable [Borderless] #9

Set: Magic The Hobbit Eternal  | Treatment: Borderless  | Annual Sales Volume: 276

ConditionSeptember 2026October 2026Change
Ungraded (Raw)$22.70$18.49-18.5% ▼
Graded (PSA/BGS/CGC 10)———

Frequently Asked Questions

What does "liquidity" mean for Magic: The Gathering cards?

Liquidity is how easily a card can be bought or sold at fair market value. We measure it using annual sales volume from PriceCharting — verified transaction counts per card per year. High-volume cards have many active buyers and sellers, so you can list and sell quickly without discounting heavily.

Why are the most liquid Magic cards mostly from the newest set?

Magic is a play-first market. The cards changing hands most often are the constructed staples and chase rares from the set currently being opened and drafted. In this snapshot, The Hobbit alone accounts for 85 of the top 100, and 98 of 100 cards were released in 2025–2026.

Do graded Magic cards trade at a premium?

Rarely, and only for a tiny slice of cards. Magic has the thinnest graded market of any major TCG — only 5 of these 100 most-liquid cards have any graded sale on record at all. Value lives in near-mint raw copies; most players and collectors never slab their cards.

How are prices sourced?

All prices come from PriceCharting daily CSV snapshots. Ungraded = loose-price, Graded = graded-price field. 30-day comparison: September 3 vs October 3, 2026.

How do I use this guide for Singapore buying and selling?

USD prices convert to SGD at approximately 1.35–1.36 (check current rates). When browsing Carousell or Telegram groups, use the ungraded price as your raw benchmark. Listings more than 20% below PriceCharting may be underpriced — or may have condition issues. Use tcgTalk Price Comparison for live SGD pricing.

Data sourced from PriceCharting daily CSV exports. Prices in USD. Comparison: September 3 vs October 3, 2026. Updated October 3, 2026. 132,632+ Magic cards tracked. Past price movements do not guarantee future performance.

Advertisement
tcgTalk Price Comparison
Check Current SGD Prices
See what these cards are selling for right now — Singapore market data across Carousell, Facebook, and SNKRDUNK.
Compare Prices →
Share this guide
End of article · Where to go next
Or browse more guides
Guide
Most Expensive Magic: The Gathering Cards 2026
tcgtalk · 10 min
Guide
Magic Reserved List Investment Guide
tcgtalk · 9 min
Guide
Top 100 Most Liquid Pokémon Cards
tcgtalk · 12 min