Why Black MTG Cards Are Expensive
Black is the colour of power, death, and sacrifice in Magic — and its most expensive cards reflect decades of Legacy and Vintage dominance. Underground Sea is the most-played dual land in Legacy, appearing in nearly every blue-black strategy from Death's Shadow to Reanimator. Mox Jet, the black Power Nine piece, commands extraordinary PSA premiums. And the Legends enchantments — Chains of Mephistopheles, The Abyss, Nether Void — are Reserved List staples with consistent competitive demand from Legacy Enchantress and Death & Taxes sideboards. Black's most expensive cards span three distinct eras: the 1993 Alpha/Beta Power Nine, the 1993 Arabian Nights first expansion (Juzam Djinn, Guardian Beast), and the 1994 Legends third expansion.
Top 20 Most Expensive Black Magic Cards
Prices in SGD (converted at 1.36 USD/SGD). Raw price reflects current market value for ungraded copies. Data: PriceCharting, May 2026.
| # | Card | Type | Raw (SGD) | Graded PSA 10 (SGD) | Annual Sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Underground Sea Magic Alpha | Reserved List Dual | $7,616 | $19,774 | 10 |
| 2 | Mox Jet Magic Alpha | Artifact (Black Mana) | $6,860 | $34,000 | 9 |
| 3 | Underground Sea Magic Beta | Reserved List Dual | $5,550 | $10,879 | 14 |
| 4 | Mox Jet Magic Beta | Artifact (Black Mana) | $5,545 | $12,019 | 15 |
| 5 | Mox Jet Magic Unlimited | Artifact (Black Mana) | $3,839 | $6,408 | 44 |
| 6 | Badlands Magic Alpha | Reserved List Dual | $3,190 | $10,714 | 9 |
| 7 | Scrubland Magic Alpha | Reserved List Dual | $2,995 | $9,444 | 10 |
| 8 | Scrubland Magic Beta | Reserved List Dual | $2,385 | $3,193 | 15 |
| 9 | Juzam Djinn Magic Arabian Nights | Reserved List Creature | $2,218 | $3,604 | 78 |
| 10 | Badlands Magic Beta | Reserved List Dual | $1,904 | $3,575 | 16 |
| 11 | Underground Sea Magic Unlimited | Reserved List Dual | $1,748 | $2,396 | 55 |
| 12 | Chains of Mephistopheles Magic Legends | Reserved List Enchantment | $1,238 | $1,463 | 85 |
| 13 | Badlands Magic Unlimited | Reserved List Dual | $835 | $1,179 | 57 |
| 14 | The Abyss Magic Legends | Reserved List Enchantment | $796 | $1,074 | 82 |
| 15 | Nether Void Magic Legends | Reserved List Enchantment | $696 | $836 | 67 |
| 16 | Scrubland Magic Unlimited | Reserved List Dual | $644 | $1,071 | 60 |
| 17 | All Hallow's Eve Magic Legends | Reserved List Sorcery | $562 | $801 | 88 |
| 18 | Invoke Prejudice Magic Legends | Reserved List Enchantment | $557 | $1,085 | 76 |
| 19 | Guardian Beast Magic Arabian Nights | Reserved List Creature | $602 | $1,135 | 79 |
| 20 | Mirror Universe Magic Legends | Reserved List Artifact | $377 | $601 | 90 |
Invoke Prejudice note: This Legends card ($557 raw, 76 annual sales) was removed from the official Gatherer database by Wizards of the Coast in 2020 due to its art's resemblance to KKK imagery. It remains legal to own but has no Scryfall entry. Included here for completeness.
Black Dual Lands
Black features three dual lands — Underground Sea (blue/black), Badlands (red/black), and Scrubland (white/black). All three are on the Reserved List and see continuous Legacy and Vintage play.
Underground Sea
The top black dual and the most played Legacy land overall. Alpha at $7,616 raw / $19,774 PSA 10 with 10 annual trades. Beta at $5,550 / $10,879 with 14 trades. Unlimited at $1,748 / $2,396 with 55 annual sales. Used in virtually every Legacy blue-black strategy: Reanimator, Death's Shadow, Dimir Tempo. The demand floor here is extremely solid — competitive players need four copies for their decks, meaning these aren't just collector pieces.
Badlands
The red/black dual used in Legacy Storm, Grixis Control, and various aggro builds. Alpha at $3,190 raw / $10,714 PSA 10 with 9 annual trades (only ~9 trades/year globally). Beta $1,904 / $3,575 with 16 trades. Unlimited $835 / $1,179 with 57 annual sales — the most accessible entry point for Badlands exposure.
Scrubland
White/black dual used in Legacy Death & Taxes and Deadguy Ale. Alpha $2,995 / $9,444 PSA 10 with 10 annual trades. Beta $2,385 / $3,193 with 15 trades. Unlimited $644 / $1,071 with 60 annual sales.
Mox Jet Breakdown
Mox Jet produces black mana for free — a one-mana ramp piece that remains restricted in Vintage and banned everywhere else. Its PSA 10 premium is extraordinary: Alpha copies at $6,860 raw reach $34,000 PSA 10, a 4.96x multiplier — the highest PSA premium ratio of any black card. Beta $5,545 raw / $12,019 PSA 10 shows a 2.17x premium. Unlimited at $3,839 / $6,408 — a 1.67x premium — reflects the larger Unlimited print run and better average card preservation. Only ~9 annual trades for Alpha Mox Jet. The Alpha PSA 10 ceiling of $34,000 makes it one of the most valuable graded specimens from the original set.
Legends Black Cards
Six of the top 20 black cards come from Magic Legends (1994) — an unusually high concentration for a single expansion. Legends introduced many powerful Reserved List enchantments that remain Legacy staples today.
Chains of Mephistopheles
At $1,238 raw / $1,463 PSA 10 with 85 annual sales, Chains is the most valuable black Legends card and one of the most complex cards ever printed. Its draw-replacement effect creates a lock with Sylvan Library. A Legacy staple in Enchantress decks and a collector's favourite for its iconic dark artwork.
The Abyss
A powerful enchantment that destroys non-artifact creatures each upkeep. At $796 raw / $1,074 PSA 10 with 82 annual sales, it sees play in Legacy Enchantress and vintage control sideboards.
Nether Void
A Legends enchantment at $696 raw / $836 PSA 10 with 67 annual sales that taxes all spells by 3 colourless. Used in Legacy Prison and Stax strategies.
All Hallow's Eve
A black/red sorcery at $562 raw / $801 PSA 10 with 88 annual sales. Used in graveyard reanimation combos across Legacy and Vintage.
Juzam Djinn
The most iconic Arabian Nights creature: at $2,218 raw / $3,604 PSA 10 with 78 annual trades, this 5/5 for four black mana that deals 1 damage to its controller per upkeep was the defining threat of early Magic. It remains a Reserved List collector piece and sees occasional Vintage play in mono-black prison strategies.
Buying Tips for Black Magic Cards
Underground Sea Unlimited: Best Liquidity
At $1,748 raw / $2,396 PSA 10 with 55 annual sales, Underground Sea Unlimited is the most liquid Reserved List dual with proven competitive demand. It's the recommended entry point for collectors who want dual land exposure without committing to the $5,000–$7,600 price range of Alpha/Beta copies.
Chains of Mephistopheles PSA Premium is Thin
The 1.18x PSA premium on Chains ($1,238 → $1,463) is unusually low for a Reserved List card. This suggests graded supply is relatively healthy or that collectors aren't prioritising gem-mint Chains. For a speculative play, finding a near-mint raw copy and submitting for grading could be worthwhile if prices develop as the population stays thin.
Badlands Alpha: Extraordinary PSA Multiple
The 3.36x PSA 10 premium on Badlands Alpha ($3,190 → $10,714) stands out as exceptional. This suggests very thin PSA 10 population for Alpha Badlands relative to demand. Alpha dual lands with gem-mint centering are extraordinarily rare — any correctly centred Alpha Badlands in near-mint condition is potentially a significant grading opportunity.
Use tcgTalk's price guide to track current Magic card prices in Singapore.
Price data sourced from PriceCharting, May 2026. SGD prices converted at 1.36 USD/SGD. Prices are indicative and may vary based on condition, edition, and market timing. This is not financial advice.